The Burden of the Human Soul: A Comparative Study of Guilt, Punishment, and Redemption in Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter and Fyodor Dostoevsky’s Crime and Punishment
- Mr. Sagar Biswas
- Nov 27, 2025
- 1 min read
Sagar Biswas
Student
Department of English
Directorate of Open and Distance Learning
University of Kalyani
Email sagarbiswas677@gmail.com
This dissertation presents a comparative study of Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter (1850) and Fyodor Dostoevsky’s Crime and Punishment (1866), focusing on how these seminal novels explore guilt, punishment, social judgment, inner conflict, redemption, suffering, and spiritual rebirth. Though shaped by different cultural and intellectual traditions—Hawthorne’s grounded in American Romanticism and Puritan ethics, and Dostoevsky’s influenced by Russian existential thought and societal unrest—both works probe the universal human experience of wrongdoing and moral transformation. The analysis contrasts public and private forms of punishment. In The Scarlet Letter, the rigid Puritan society inflicts visible, gendered stigma upon Hester Prynne, while in Crime and Punishment, the fragmented psyche of Raskolnikov exposes the hidden anguish stemming from his crime. The study demonstrates how both authors move beyond rigid notions of right and wrong, portraying punishment as a profound spiritual and psychological trial rather than mere legal consequence. The role of women is central, with Hester and Sonya representing compassion, resilience, and ethical guidance within oppressive frameworks. The dissertation also highlights Hawthorne’s focus on personal conscience and rebellion against societal judgment alongside Dostoevsky’s engagement with free will, moral accountability, and suffering as a path to redemption. Ultimately, this comparative inquiry affirms that true atonement arises through pain, reflection, and spiritual awakening, reinforcing the enduring moral significance of these literary masterpieces.
Key Words
Hawthorne, Scarlet Letter, Burden of Human Soul, Crime and Punishment
Comments